Navigation
MGK Pool Service

Pool Filter Reviews and Comparisons – Residential

Swimming pool filter information to help you choose what type and size is best for you and your pool.

It is not a matter of opinion when comparing pool filter types. There is no arguing that Diatomaceous Earth (D.E) does the best job of filtering and clearing water. D.E filters are able to catch the smallest particles (fact).

The only other two filter types are Cartridge, and Sand. Again, it is not a matter of opinion, Cartridge filters do the next best job, and then Sand. There are however, some pro’s and con’s of all 3 types. While all filters will keep the water clear, one type is most expensive, A couple are easier to maintain, and one is better for the environment.

When you are finished with this examination, you should be able to select the pool filter that is most appropriate for your circumstances. Also, I will share my opinion, explaining which specific filters are best for cleaning and maintaining residential inground and above-ground swimming pools, all without your eyes glazing over (hopefully).

Filter Types & Efficiency: Sand, D.E, & Cartridge

Sand Filters

Sand is the oldest and most economical choice. Sand is however, the least efficient without the use of flocculant or filter aids. Filter aids will shorten the life of the sand or cause channeling. Sand filters are only able to grab particles of 40 microns. As a point of reference, a grain of table salt is about 100 microns, human hair is about 75 microns. With good eyesight, you can actually see a 40 micron particle (dirt).

Todays residential sand filters evenly distribute unfiltered pool water across the top of the filter, over a bed of sand (white silica preferred). The pump pressure pushes the water down to the bottom, where the water flows through piping (laterals) with holes so small the sand can’t pass, and this filtered water is then directed back to the pool.

Pool dirt accumulates in the top of the filter, with sufficient debris, the water gets harder to push down, and tank pressure rises (this is why you have a gauge). When pressure rises 7-10 psi, you backwash out the dirt.

PRO Tip* Dont buy a sand filter, but if you do, go big on the filter size and low on the pump pressure. Best to run a 2 speed pump on low for 24 hours, than a single speed on high for 8 hours.

Buying Tip* It is the sand that cleans the water, not the name of the filter.

Pro’s

Sand filters are the least expensive. They require the least amount of maintenance, and are easiest to winterize. Sand media lasts 5 to 7 years. They all have a backwash cycle, so no need to get dirty cleaning the filter. Sand filters date back to 1804 when they were first used to purify water.

Con’s

Sand filters are the least efficient, so clearing dirty pools takes longer. Not appropriate for super dusty areas like Arizona, and require extensive back wash cycles for cleaning, which wastes a lot of water. You may require longer run times to clear pools in high pollen areas. Longer run times means higher energy bills.

Channeling is another concern, it occurs when pump pressure is excessive, causing channels to form between the top and the bottom of the filter. The water follows the easy path instead of evenly filtering down through all the sand. Filter aids such as flocculant/flox can also cause channeling.

With its inability to catch small debris, small bits of algae are allowed to pass through the filter and take hold, versus getting filtered out as it would in either of the other two filter types.

Cartridge Filters

Cartridge filters are the newest type of filter, and are the second best with it’s ability to grab particles @ 15 -25 microns.

These fiber filter types have become extremely popular in the past few years, especially with above-ground swimming pools. Water enters the housing, water is then forced through the porous fiber cartridge material, trapping all particles larger than 15-25 Microns on the surface. Once the water makes it to the inner core, filtered water is directed back to the pool.

Cartridge filters are used in many industries including water purification for drinking. The quality of the filter is determined by the density of the pleats, as well as how deep they are are.

It is best not to over size the pump when going with a cartridge filter. High water volume can beat up the filter, and require it to need replacing earlier than usual. High volume pumps, with high HP (horse power), run on high, will also embed dirt into the filter, or cause blow by. Always best to run pumps on lower speeds, even if it extends the run cycle.

Buying Tip* Remember it is the cartridge the actually cleans the water. You can buy a Unicel cartridge for the cheapest cartridge filter on the planet, and it will clean the water as good as the best brands like Pentair or Hayward.

Cleaning Tip* There is only one tool made and designed for cleaning a cartridge filter, it is called the Aquacomb. It makes cleaning the filter a much easier task. For best results use a spray on cleaner like BioGuard, it will help clean off sun tan lotions and other hard to remove debris. Read our article on Pool Cartridge Filter Cleaner for more info.

Pro’s

Cartridge filters are more efficient than sand. Require a lot less water to clean. These are the most environmentally friendly option.

Cost has come down considerable lately, making not much more than a sand, but much less than DE.

They take up less room, and are capable of cleaning large pools

Con’s

An over-sized pump will embed dirt into the filter, and the high pressure will beat up the fibers of the filter, requiring the cartridge to be replaced more often. I recommend a 1 HP or even a .75 HP pump

Lacking a backwash cycle like the other filter types, you have to disassemble the filter every time the cartridge requires cleaning.

 

D.E. Filters

D.E filters are the most efficient, they can catch particles as small as 4 microns. These filters are capable of giving you the cleanest and clearest water possible.

Pro’s

Clearest water possible! Clears dirty water fastest.

Con’s

Loss of water during backwashing is a major con. Requires new media (DE Powder) after every backwash. Most expensive to buy, and to maintain.

It needs to be disassembled and cleaned once or twice a year, because backwashing just doesnt clean it well enough.

D.E backwash is not hazardous, and though it is code to have a separation tank here in Massachusetts, and other states. I have never seen one on a residential pool. D.E does pose serious health risks in dry powder form, but that can be managed if handled in an open and well ventilated area. Basically, don’t breath it in, or get it in your eyes.

I would also note that they do not operate effectively when pumps are set to run on low speeds.

Bigger Is Better For A Reason

If your pool stays relatively clear and free of algae, just about any properly sized filter will work. But if your pool gets taken over by algae, you’re going to want a pool filter that is quick and easy to clean, and one that can handle the job. While no pool filter can keep up with live algae, once the algae is dead, you will need to filter a lot of suspended particles out of the water. For this reason I recommend going big!

Some will argue that sand filters become more effective when they start to clog up with dirt, and that over sizing it will reduce its effectiveness, but it has been my experience that the more filter area the better. Problems occur when pool salespeople and builders allow the filter to be undersized for local environment, and pool size.

Homeowners here in Massachusetts will want a large efficient filter to deal with opening their pool in the spring, after the pool has been dormant for 8 months. This is especially true for homeowners that use a mesh safety cover when they close their pool. Getting your pool clear and clean can take two weeks, or it can take 24 hrs, its up to you. The more you oversize your filter, the less maintenance you will have to do, and the longer it will last.

Whats The Best Pool Filter Type For Your Pool?

First, I want to say, if you call me to get your pool clean, and opt for my clean and clear package, where I guarantee your pool to be clean and clear within 72 hours, I am showing up with my own DE filter. I’m a professional, and DE is clearly the filter of choice of any professional.

If your not mechanically inclined, I would say a big sand filter may be the best choice for you. Or if your selling your home and need to replace your equipment. Sand would make a good choice.

There is no escaping the fact that we are moving into a time in this country, where we need to be more responsible, and preserve more water. If everyone went to cartridge filters, we would save millions, if not billions of gallons of water every year.

Filter Recommendations

I have given you all you need to know to make your choice. below I make recommendations for each type, giving you the best in breed for each media type.

Filter Brand Recommendations

Here’s the thing… Its the media that cleans the water and traps dirt. Its the media that stops dirt from returning to the pool. White silica sand works just as good in an inexpensive Reliant filter, as it does in a more expensive Hayward or Pentair filter. Celtron DE does not care what brand name housing it is put into. A cartridge filter element works as good in one filter as another.

To this end, I have recommended some lower cost alternatives that have proven themselves out over the years, along with some of my favorites of more popular band names.

Above Ground Sand Filters Recommendations

My top choice in this class is the Reliant 19″, it holds 175 lbs of sand and is virtually bullet proof. It will last 15 to 20 years, or even longer. You will find it extremely effective for the following above ground pool sizes.

  • 18′ round
  • 21′ round
  • 24′ round
  • 15′ x 30′ oval

I recommend the Reliant 24″ for any of the bigger above ground swimming pools listed below. This is really an inground filter, as it holds three hundred pounds of sand. Though if you value my opinion, bigger is better

  • 18′ x 33′ Oval
  • 30′ Round
  • 33′ Round

Above Ground D.E Filters

My top choice for above ground DE filters is definitely the Pentair / Sta-Rite PLD Series. It is expensive, which is why I give you another option below, but I have seen a 24 round pool go a whole season without this filter needing to cleaned once, it has similar material to the filter I clean in the video at the bottom of this article. It actually looks new after cleaning it.

The only catch is there is no backwash cycle, you have to remove the element and hose it off manually. The filter alone is lke 500.00 bucks, and can usually be found on amazon. We sell the whole system with a pump for $630.00 in our online pool store.

The Pentair / Sta-Rite PLD Series DE filter would suit any size pool.

Above ground DE pool filter runner up / honorable mention

Next I would recommend the Hayward EC50. This model has a bump handle for prolonging the life of the D.E. The EC50 would be a good fit for the following pool sizes. I would definitely recommend comparing pricing from Amazon.com, and our store.

  • 18′ round
  • 21′ round
  • 24′ round
  • 15′ x 30′ oval

For bigger above ground pools, I would like to see you go with the Hayward EC60 or EC65. They are extremely durable and will maintain any pool with ease. They also have the bump handle.

Above Ground Cartridge Filters

We by an off brand filter called Reliant, and put a 100 square foot Unicel cartridge in it, and package it with a 2 speed pump, and premium hoses, with valves all for only $350.00. 100 squ ft cartridge filter system

This is enough filter for any size above ground pool. I would run it on low speed 24 hours a day.

Inground Cartridge Filter Recommendationsinground cartridge filter

I only recommend one in this category. The Sta-Rite S8M150 (seen on the right). This filter is very efficient, and requires very little regular maintenance.

One Caveat: This is a bad choice for those with two speed pumps, as it requires a minimum pump speed of 50GPM. Which means you would always have to run your pump on high. It would be better matched with a variable speed pump where you could dial the gallons per minute (GPM) right to 50.

Inground Sand Filters

S310T2 Hayward Filter

 

The Hayward S310T2 Pro-Series 30-Inch Top-Mount Pool Sand Filter holds 500 lbs of sand, and will maintain in-ground pools up to 40,000 gallons. It could be considered overkill for a 16′ x 32′ or smaller pool, but it cost about the same as a Hayward S200, and holds 300lbs more media (extreme value).

 

 

 

 

 

Inground D.E Filters.

Inground de filter

I am a huge fan of Pentair inground D.E filters. Especially the Quad Pro model
seen above. It will easily maintain any residential inground pools. When shopping, remember, the bigger the square footage, the bigger the clean. I shot the video below earlier this year (2016).

Pool Filter Reviews Conclusion

Choosing the right filter will save you a ton time and headaches over the coming years. I hope this article will help you to spend more time in your pool, and less time cleaning and working on it. If you liked this article, you might also like to read:

Please ask any questions, or add your opinion in the comments below. Thanks!

0 Comment

    Leave a Comment

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *